Saturday, February 18, 2006 2:00 AM

Top Five Records
Late at night, unwinding on the couch after work. It's cold tonight, getting hard to type because my fingers are going numb.
As some of you know, I am a bit of a DMB fan. Tonight I got an e-mail from the administrator at Ants Marching in answer to a question, and for the first time ever, I intentionally clicked on a Gooooooogle Ad in my Gmail.
It was an Amazon ad for a Dave and Tim (Reynolds) live album, "Live at Luther College." Now, I already have that album. But I heard somewhere that that album is one of Amazon's top five buyer-rated albums of all time. So I decided to click through the ad and read some of the reviews. And the reviews support the claim. Here are a few of my favorite excerpts, slightly abridged:
Not a big DMB fan, but this set is fantastic!
Having lived with two DMB fans, one of whom virtually worships the man and his band, I have been exposed to the vast majority of their tunes. I think they're talented, but between Dave's somewhat indecipherable vocals and the sometimes over-the-top instrumentation, I find that whatever message they're trying to convey often gets buried.
That being said, "Live at Luther College" is most definitely one (or two, if a two-disc set can't count as one) of the ten recordings I'd want with me if I were stranded on a desert island.
There are thousands of recordings that use electric guitar and of which I'm a huge fan, but if I had to choose, I prefer the purity of acoustic guitar. The use of acoustic guitars alone gives this set a huge edge.
And Tim Reynolds is a virtuoso--probably as technically gifted as many respected classical guitarist, but with an equally impeccable ability to reinvent each of Dave's songs so that they have every bit as much groove, humor, emotion, and force (and often more) as they did with his full band backing him up...
And while they take their guitars to the very limits of unplugged rock, Dave's voice is still able to shine through clearly...
Virtually all of the power and emotion is generated by the musicians themselves, not by special effects or gadgets, and you can really feel what a memorable experience it must have been to attend that show.
Amazing
The first time i listen to this album, i was blown away. So amazing how these two men can make daves songs into something totally different. The next time i listened to this album, i was laying in bed at 11 at night, jus relaxin, under the influence of hallucinagenic mushrooms. n it was the most amazing night of my life. the emotion on this album is unbelievable. the whole song tripping billies is amazing, n i still feel like im on the shrooms wenever i listen to the song. easily the best version of tripping billies...this is one of the best albums ever recorded.
simply amazing
The stand out song on this CD is "#41". Dave's voice is filled with emotion and the acoustic solo to close the song is almost haunting in the melody and precision Tim Reynolds gives it. This is the BEST live album ever made. Buy it for a truly amazing acoustic experience.
It doesn't get much better than this
Tim Reynolds and Dave Matthews merge into one being on this album, communicating to such an extent that I would not be scared to compare it with such associations as Coltrane/Cannonball, Parker/Gillespie and more recently DiMeola/McLaughlin/DeLucia or Lagrene/Luc.
Great songs, very surprising sound for a live recording and everything just clicks.











